Po raz pierwszy w historii w Pro Bowl nie dojdzie do starcia American Football Conference kontra National Football Conference. Nowy format, który ma naprawić tracącą popularność w Stanach rozgrywkę, polega na wyborze draftowaniu zawodników przez dwie legendy NFL. Z zawodników, na których fani mogli głosować przez ponad dwa miesiące i którzy dostali najwięcej głosów, Jerry Rice oraz Deion Sanders zabawili się w wybieranie zawodników do swoich drużyn. Asystowało im po jednym zawodniku z obrony oraz ataku, którzy otrzymali najwięcej głosów.
Team Sanders wybierał sam "The Prime" z pomocą Drew Breesa z New Orleans Saints oraz Roberta Quinna z St. Louis Rams. Po drugiej stronie Team Rice draftowali "World" oraz Jamaal Charles z Kansas City Chiefs z J.J. Wattem z Houston Texans.
Składy nie uwzględniają zawodników, którzy zostali wybrani w głosowaniu, ale z powodu kontuzji lub grze w finałach konferencji oraz oczywiście Super Bowl zostali zamienieni.
Team Sanders:
Quarterbacks
Cam Newton (Carolina Panthers)
Nick Foles (Philadelphia Eagles)
Andrew Luck (Indianapolis Colts)
Running Backs
Jamaal Charles (Kansas City Chiefs) (C)
Eddie Lacy (Green Bay Packers)
Marcel Reece (Oakland Raiders)
Alfred Morris (Washington Redskins)
Wide Receivers
DeSean Jackson (Philadelphia Eagles)
A. J. Green (Cincinnati Bengals)
Antonio Brown (Pittsburgh Steelers)
Dez Bryant (Dallas Cowboys)
Tight Ends
Jason Witten (Dallas Cowboys)
Jordan Cameron (Cleveland Browns)
Offensive Tackles
Trent Williams (Washington Redskins)
Duane Brown (Houston Texans) [a][13]
Branden Albert (Kansas City Chiefs)
Offensive Guards
Logan Mankins (New England Patriots)
Marshal Yanda (Baltimore Ravens)
Kyle Long (Chicago Bears)
Centers
Mike Pouncey (Miami Dolphins)
Alex Mack (Cleveland Browns)
Defensive Ends
Greg Hardy (Carolina Panthers)
Mario Williams (Buffalo Bills)
J.J. Watt (Houston Texans) (C)
Defensive Tackles
Ndamukong Suh (Detroit Lions)
Dontari Poe (Kansas City Chiefs)
Gerald McCoy (Tampa Bay Buccaneers)
Outside Linebackers
Terrell Suggs (Baltimore Ravens)
Tamba Hali (Kansas City Chiefs)
Brian Orakpo (Washington Redskins)
Inside Linebackers
Paul Posluszny (Jacksonville Jaguars)
Luke Kuechly (Carolina Panthers)
Cornerbacks
Patrick Peterson (Arizona Cardinals)
Brent Grimes (Miami Dolphins)
Darrelle Revis (Tampa Bay Buccaneers)
Tim Jennings (Chicago Bears)
Free Safeties
Eric Berry (Kansas City Chiefs)
Eric Weddle (San Diego Chargers)
T.J. Ward (Cleveland Browns)
Punter
Brandon Fields (Miami Dolphins)
Placekicker
Justin Tucker (Baltimore Ravens)
Return Specialist
Cordarrelle Patterson (Minnesota Vikings)
Long Snapper
J. J. Jansen (Carolina Panthers)
Special Teamer
Matthew Slater (New England Patriots)
Team Rice
Quarterbacks
Drew Brees (New Orleans Saints) (C)
Alex Smith (Kansas City Chiefs)
Philip Rivers (San Diego Chargers)
Running Backs
Matt Forte (Chicago Bears)
LeSean McCoy (Philadelphia Eagles)
DeMarco Murray (Dallas Cowboys)
Mike Tolbert (Carolina Panthers)
Wide Receivers
Larry Fitzgerald (Arizona Cardinals)
Josh Gordon (Cleveland Browns)
Brandon Marshall (Chicago Bears)
Alshon Jeffery (Chicago Bears)
Tight Ends
Jimmy Graham (New Orleans Saints)
Tony Gonzalez (Atlanta Falcons)
Offensive Tackles
Jordan Gross (Carolina Panthers)
Joe Thomas (Cleveland Browns)
Tyron Smith (Dallas Cowboys)
Offensive Guards
Ben Grubbs (New Orleans Saints)
Evan Mathis (Philadelphia Eagles)
Jahri Evans (New Orleans Saints)
Centers
Ryan Kalil (Carolina Panthers)
Nick Mangold (New York Jets)
Defensive Ends
Cameron Wake (Miami Dolphins)
Robert Quinn (St. Louis Rams) (C)
Cameron Jordan (New Orleans Saints)
Defensive Tackles
Kyle Williams (Buffalo Bills)
Jason Hatcher (Dallas Cowboys)
Marcell Dareus (Buffalo Bills)
Outside Linebackers
Justin Houston (Kansas City Chiefs)
John Abraham (Arizona Cardinals)
Robert Mathis (Indianapolis Colts)
Inside Linebackers
Vontaze Burfict (Cincinnati Bengals)
Derrick Johnson (Kansas City Chiefs)
Cornerbacks
Alterraun Verner (Tennessee Titans)
Joe Haden (Cleveland Browns)
Brandon Flowers (Kansas City Chiefs)
Antonio Cromartie (New York Jets)
Safeties
Antrel Rolle (New York Giants)
Jairus Byrd (Buffalo Bills)
Eric Reid (San Francisco 49ers)
Punter
John Hekker (St. Louis Rams)
Placekicker
Stephen Gostkowski (New England Patriots)
Return Specialist
Dexter McCluster (Kansas City Chiefs)
Long Snapper
Matt Overton (Indianapolis Colts)
Special Teamer
Justin Bethel (Arizona Cardinals)
